01 · 来龙去脉
八十年,一条线
他们在联合国的投票有多相近(投票一致度)。色带是从数据本身发现的时期;圆点是重要时刻;下方是各国的领导人。
大会对全文的记录表决中的投票一致度:投票相同计1,弃权对赞成或反对计½,赞成对反对计0。来源:Nations on Record(Voeten等人的一致度分数;联合国数字图书馆)。
简而言之
指数是怎样算出的
每项得分从 −100 到 +100,按其权重计入。各部分相加即为指数。
每个分数都遵循“工作原理”中写明的固定规则;不涉及AI。以下是这对国家的步骤,使用它自己的数字。 工作原理 · JSON · 下载 · 步骤为英文。
Inputs: Rules 0.2: no security score for a pair with a UN non-member observer State..
Inputs: Tracked groups: EU, AU, ARAB, ASEAN, BRICS, G7, G20, GCC, P5.
指数需要投票分和贸易分。这里缺少其中一项,因此不显示指数。
言辞(双方如何谈论对方)会显示但不计分,人员层面(移民、难民、足球)也从不计分。
分数的可靠程度取决于其背后的数据。共四级:高、中、低、无。阈值写在“工作原理”中;等级不改变分数,只说明可以信任到什么程度。 工作原理
言辞(双方如何谈论对方)只计数、不计分,因此没有等级。重要时刻和人员层面是背景信息,从不计入分数。
01 · 来龙去脉
他们在联合国的投票有多相近(投票一致度)。色带是从数据本身发现的时期;圆点是重要时刻;下方是各国的领导人。
大会对全文的记录表决中的投票一致度:投票相同计1,弃权对赞成或反对计½,赞成对反对计0。来源:Nations on Record(Voeten等人的一致度分数;联合国数字图书馆)。
02 · 言
它们从未真正进行过的对话:每个十年,各国政府在联合国一般性辩论发言中如何谈论对方。
巴勒斯坦不是联合国会员国。巴勒斯坦解放组织自 1974 年起是观察员;巴勒斯坦直到 1998 年才获准在大会一般性辩论中发言(大会第 52/250 号决议),2012 年成为非会员观察员国(第 67/19 号决议)。因此在这些数据中,巴勒斯坦的发言始于 1998 年,黎巴嫩的发言始于 1946 年;在此之前没有巴勒斯坦的发言可供引用。
在较早的发言中,“巴勒斯坦”常指那片土地或围绕它的冲突,而不是一个政府或一个民族。引语按固定规则挑选,未经编辑,所以一些早期引语说的就是这个。
The Palestine refugees had been heartened when they had heard Mr. Acheson, Secretary of State of the United States, declare at the 222nd meeting that, as an interim measure, the General Assembly should make the necessary provision for the maintenance of those refugees until the time when they could again become self-sustaining members of the Near Eastern communities.
Mr. C. MALIK · 黎巴嫩 · 1949
I now turn to the painful question of the Palestine refugees, which affects all the Arab countries, including my own.
Mr. Karame · 黎巴嫩 · 1959
As early as 1949, in order to fulfil the “messianic destiny of the people of Israel”, more than a million Palestinians were expelled from their homes and land by terrorism, violence and fire.
Mr. SALEM · 黎巴嫩 · 1969
Indeed, Lebanon is the victim of the Israeli usurpation of the Arab land of Palestine, the expulsion of the Palestinian people and the tense crisis that has constantly held the region in its grip following that aggression.
Boutros · 黎巴嫩 · 1979
The recent developments on the questions of Afghanistan, Namibia, Western Sahara, the Iran-Iraq conflict, Kampuchea and Cyprus are encouraging and make us very hopeful that efforts will be intensified to reach genuine solutions to the question of southern Lebanon, the Israeli occupation of a part of Lebanon, the Middle East question, and, in particular, the question of the Palestinian people.
Mr. FAKHRURY · 黎巴嫩 · 1988
In those statements, Mr. Barak stressed several no's, namely, no to a return to the 1967 borders, no to the partition of Jerusalem, no to dismantling the settlements, and no to the return of Palestinian refugees.
Salim El-Hoss, Prime Minister · 黎巴嫩 · 1999
A just and comprehensive peace in the Middle East can last only if it is protected by international legitimacy and if efforts are undertaken to implement all of the resolutions pertaining to the Middle East conflict on the Palestinian, Syrian and Lebanese tracks.
Yasser Arafat, President · 巴勒斯坦 · 1999
Indeed, it is very unfortunate that the Arab Middle East, a region that gave rise to the three monotheistic religions, has been an area of tension, conflict and war ever since the Nakba, the tragedy that befell Palestine in 1948 and displaced its people.
General Michel Sleimann, President · 黎巴嫩 · 2009
How can one conceive of holding negotiations without agreement on the terms of reference and the objective of those negotiations, which the whole world has unanimously agreed upon, namely ending the Israeli occupation of the territories occupied in 1967, establishing the State of Palestine, with Jerusalem as its capital, reaching a just and agreed upon solution to the question of Palestinian refugees on the basis of resolution 194 (III) of 1948, and achieving peace on all the Palestinian, Syrian and Lebanese tracks, as affirmed in the Arab Peace Initiative, which provides a precious opportunity that must be seized to achieve peace?
Mahmoud Abbas, President · 巴勒斯坦 · 2009
The other began in 1948, when waves of Palestinians were displaced to the countries of diaspora and particularly to Lebanon, where they are still living in camps, nurturing the dream of return, and where they have now been awaiting a political settlement and the implementation of resolution 194 (III) for 71 years.
General Michel Aoun, President · 黎巴嫩 · 2019
This must be done in a manner that will achieve freedom, independence and justice for the Palestinian people in their homeland, rectify the historical injustice inflicted upon them, achieve security and safety for all their neighbours, lead to a just peace throughout the Middle East, including on the Syrian and Lebanese tracks, and thus usher in a new era of stability, progress, prosperity, coexistence and good-neighbourliness.
Mahmoud Abbas, President · 巴勒斯坦 · 2010
We urge the revival of a new political track aimed at finding a just and permanent solution to the Palestinian question based on the resolutions of international legitimacy, the principle of the two-state solution, ensuring the right of both states to a secure and dignified existence as ratified by your General Assembly with a majority of 142 states out of 164 states in the New York Declaration.
Joseph Aoun, President · 黎巴嫩 · 2025
And now, Israel is launching further aggression on our brotherly people in Lebanon.
Mahmoud Abbas, President · 巴勒斯坦 · 2024
引语规则:每个十年,取该十年最后一次发言中一方提及另一方的第一句话。所有国家对和双方都适用同一规则。
当黎巴嫩发言时
当巴勒斯坦发言时
同一句话中的关键词,而不是对谁做了什么的判断。
03 · 行
在联合国与各自投票最相似的国家。中间的国家与两者投票都相似。
商品出口,现价美元。IMF,经由 Nations on Record。
箭头宽度:每个方向的年度商品流量。柱条:占各国贸易总额的比例。
自1946年以来,未记录到两国政府之间的武装冲突,也未记录到并肩作战。
计入:两国政府处于对立两方,或一方派兵与另一方作战。与驻在对方国家的武装团体之间的战斗不计入。 UCDP 双边数据集 26.1,数据截至2025年。
欧盟、非洲联盟、阿拉伯国家联盟、东盟、金砖国家、七国集团、二十国集团、海湾合作委员会、五常及联合国区域组。北约计入安全。
评分用相同的数据比较每一对联合国会员国。对这一对来说,部分数据不可能存在,因此这里以其他来源作为背景展示。
巴勒斯坦 是联合国非会员观察员国,不能在联合国大会投票,因此双方没有共同投票。
从不计入分数。
两国之间没有通报世界贸易组织的贸易协定。
已通报世界贸易组织的协定,已生效或已签署。当欧盟等集团作为一方签署时,协定把其成员与另一方联系起来,而不是成员彼此之间。 状态以通报世界贸易组织的内容为准;不核实协定目前是否仍在这两国之间适用。 来源:世界贸易组织区域贸易协定数据库。
联合国安理会对黎巴嫩实施制裁,所有联合国会员国都必须执行。
联合国安理会、欧盟、美国和英国针对国家的制裁制度;不含专题清单(恐怖主义、网络、人权),也不含其他国家自己的清单。制裁制度可能针对政府、官员或企业;它不是衡量两国关系的指标。 来源:欧盟制裁地图、OFAC(美国财政部)、英国政府。 从不计入分数。
04 · 人
政府争吵;人们迁徙、求学、逃难、踢足球。这些都不计入指数。
国际移民存量,联合国经社部2024。 按出生地统计:包括难民,以及在现有边界形成之前出生的人,例如出生在后来分裂的国家。
联合国难民署。仅限难民和寻求庇护者:抵达时获得公民身份的人不计入。 联合国难民署的数字不包括在近东救济工程处(联合国为他们设立的机构)登记的巴勒斯坦难民。破折号表示这里没有统计他们,而不是说没有。
回答由人工智能语言模型撰写,而非网站编辑。它可能出错;以本页的数字和来源为准。