Germany

2 sentences about Belgium · since 1946 · Germany profile
+71
Very close

Belgium

36 sentences about Germany · since 1946 · Belgium profile
Borders are for orientation only and say nothing about disputed territory.

Dashed outlines: areas whose status is disputed. Shapes follow Natural Earth, which draws some areas along recognised borders and others by who administers them on the ground; they say nothing about who is right, and front lines of current wars are not shown.

In short

  • They are military allies in NATO, and no armed conflict between them is recorded.NATO allies
  • At the UN their vote agreement is 97% (2022–2024), among the highest either of them has with any country.97%vote agreement
  • Trade in goods ($170 billion a year) is very important for Belgium, less so for Germany.$170 billiona year
  • In its UN General Debate speeches, Belgium names Germany far more often than the reverse (36 sentences against 2).2 · 36sentences
  • 80,000 people born in Germany live in Belgium (UN DESA counts place of birth, however long ago they moved).80,000people
Written by fixed rules from the data below — no AI.

How the index is built

Each score runs from −100 to +100 and counts by its weight. The parts add up to the index.

UN votes 35% +30 score +86 · Vote agreement 97%High confidence
Trade 20% +18 score 92 · $170 billion a yearHigh confidence
Security 30% +15 score +50 · NATO alliesHigh confidence
Shared clubs 15% +8 score 50 · 2 shared groupsHigh confidence
Words–Not scored until people check the stance labels (0 of 38 checked)
Index+71
What matters to you? Adjust the weights
Explain this scorehow each number is built, step by step

Every score follows fixed rules written out on How it works; no AI is involved. Here are the steps for this pair, with its own numbers. How it works · JSON · Downloads

UN votes +86

  1. Votes are compared with each country's own voting partners, not with all pairs: most of the world votes alike, so a global ranking would make France–Germany +62 and Canada–United States +6.
  2. Among Germany's 191 voting partners, Belgium ranks 12 (1 is the closest). That is position 94 on a scale from 0 (the furthest partner) to 100 (the closest).
  3. Among Belgium's 191 voting partners, Germany ranks 16: position 92.
  4. The two positions are averaged (93) and stretched to the range −100 to +100: +86.

Inputs: Vote agreement 97% on recorded votes, 2022–2024 (the same vote counts 1, an abstention against a yes or a no ½).

Trade 92

  1. Trade is scored by how much the more dependent side relies on it: the larger of the two shares of total trade, here 15.9%.
  2. On a log scale, 0.1% or less scores 0 and 25% or more scores 100 (a percentile would make 0.1% of a country's trade look like a middling tie).
  3. (log10(15.9%) − log10(0.1%)) ÷ (log10(25%) − log10(0.1%)) × 100 = 92, kept between 0 and 100, so the score is 92.

Inputs: Goods trade both ways: $170 billion a year, 2023–2025 (IMF) · 5.33% of Germany's trade, 15.9% of Belgium's.

Security +50

  1. No fighting on opposite sides is recorded in the last 30 years, so security can only push up.
  2. Both in NATO: +50.
  3. No fighting side by side is recorded: +0.
  4. Sum 50, capped at 80: 50.

Inputs: Opposed: never. Data to 2025. · Both are NATO members.

Shared clubs 50

  1. Each tracked group both belong to adds 25, and so does the same UN regional group. Capped at 100.
  2. 1 shared group (EU) + the same regional group (WEOG) = 2 × 25 = 50.

Inputs: Tracked groups: EU, AU, ARAB, ASEAN, BRICS, G7, G20, GCC, P5.

Index +71

ScoreValueWeightCounts forAdds
UN votes863535%+30.1
Trade922020%+18.4
Security503030%+15.0
Shared clubs501515%+7.5

The index is the weighted average of the scores that exist: (35×86 + 20×92 + 30×50 + 15×50) ÷ 100 = +71.0, shown as +71. Labels: 55 and up Very close, 25 Close, 0 Neutral, −30 Distant, below Opposed. Weights are yours to change above.

Words (what the two say about each other) are shown but not scored, and the people layer (migration, refugees, football) never is.

How sure are we?how much data stands behind each number

A score is only as good as the data under it. Four levels: High, Medium, Low, None. The thresholds are written on How it works; the level does not change a score, it tells you how far to trust it. How it works

UN votesHigh271 shared votes on whole texts in 2022–2024, the years the headline share covers. With that many, a share is good to about ±6 points.
TradeHighGoods trade is reported in 3 of the 3 years 2023–2025. Goods only, from customs data (IMF); services and energy pipelines are not in it.
SecurityHighThe Uppsala Conflict Data Program covers every state up to 2025. It counts only conflicts with at least 25 battle deaths a year.
Shared clubsHighThe list of tracked groups is fixed; membership is checked by hand.
IndexHighAs sure as the weaker of its two required parts, votes and trade. Security and shared clubs add to it but never make it surer.

Do their voting positions really differ?

In 2025, Germany stood at +0.97 (90% range +0.84 to +1.12) and Belgium at +0.88 (+0.75 to +1.01) on the main dimension of UN voting. The gap is 0.10. Their 90% ranges overlap: from their votes alone we cannot tell the two positions apart.

Positions are the ideal points of Bailey, Strezhnev and Voeten, estimated from every recorded vote; higher means voting more like the United States and Western democracies. They are not a moral score.

Words (what the two say about each other) are counted, not scored, so they carry no level. Moments and the people layer are context and never enter a score.

01 · The story so far

Eighty years, one line

How closely they voted at the UN (vote agreement). Bands are eras found in the data itself; dots are moments; below, who led each country.

Vote agreement on recorded General Assembly votes on whole texts: the same vote counts 1, an abstention against a yes or a no ½, a yes against a no 0. Source: Nations on Record (agreement score of Voeten et al.; UN Digital Library). Leaders: Wikidata, checked by hand.

1973–1988
96%
vote agreement
1989–2024
98%
Steady

From the data

1973The first time Belgium named Germany in a UN General Debate speech.
1993The first time Germany named Belgium in a UN General Debate speech.
2008Their highest recorded trade in goods, adjusted for inflation: $250 billion both ways in 2025 US dollars ($167 billion in the dollars of the time).
Found in the data by four fixed rules, the same for every pair, not chosen by an editor. Never part of a score. The rules
  • Voting: the year with the biggest difference in vote agreement between the ten years before it and the ten years from it, if that difference is at least 15 points.
  • Armed conflict: every period of consecutive years in which UCDP records the two on opposite sides.
  • Trade: the year with the highest trade in goods both ways, adjusted for inflation with US consumer prices (BLS), if trade is recorded in at least five years.
  • Speeches: for each of the two, the first year it named the other in its UN General Debate speech, counted from the first year both voted at the UN (before that, a name can mean a territory or a state not yet independent).

02 · Say

In their own words

The conversation they never quite had: for each decade, what each government said about the other in its UN General Debate speech.

1940s
The information which it supplied to the Council bears chiefly on the help which the Spanish Government gave to the traitor Degrelle, one of the principal German agents in Belgium, in allowing him to escape the fate he deserved for his political crimes and his crimes under common law. Mr. Van Langenhove · Belgium · 1946
1950s
Yet another sensitive spot is in Europe, where Germany is divided by the Iron Curtain. Mr. Wigny · Belgium · 1958
1960s
Should all Europe seek among all its peoples, whatever their régimes or alliances, regional agreements to reduce tension, limit armaments, increase economic and technical co-operation, and, after a quarter of a century, clear up the problems of Germany and of Berlin? Mr. HARMEL · Belgium · 1969
1970s
The Minister for Foreign Affairs of the Federal Republic of Germany Mr. Hans-Dietrich Genscher, spoke from this rostrum on 26 September in a particularly explicit speech on behalf of the countries of the European Community on the principal subjects of concern in foreign policy [see 8th meeting, paras. 135-200]. Simonet · Belgium · 1978
1990s
My Belgian colleague, Willy Claes, has already explained the position of the 12 members of the European Community. Mr. KINKEL · Germany · 1993
We are delighted to have you presiding over our proceedings. 8 My German ministerial colleague, Mr. Klaus Kinkel, spoke this morning on behalf of the European Union. Mr. Willy Claes, Deputy Prime Minister · Belgium · 1994
2010s
Today we Germans are grateful to the courageous people in France, Belgium, Luxembourg, Italy and many other countries of Europe for having the courage to befriend us — their former enemies — as new and lasting partners after the Second World War. Mr. Sigmar Gabriel, Vice-Chancellor and Federal Minister for Foreign Affairs · Germany · 2017
In the Security Council we have taken, together with Germany and Kuwait, a position against the escalating violence, proposing a humanitarian draft resolution last week aiming to achieve a ceasefire and protect the millions of civilians living that area. Mr. Charles Michel, Prime Minister · Belgium · 2019
2020s
Together with Germany. Alexander de Croo, Prime Minister · Belgium · 2023

Quote rule: for each decade, the first sentence in the latest speech of that decade in which one names the other. Same rule for every pair and both sides.

Who talks about whom

GermanyBelgium

Words next to the name

When Germany speaks

cooperation1
gratitude1

When Belgium speaks

dialogue3
occupation2
gratitude1
invasion1

A keyword in the same sentence, not a judgement of who did what.

03 · Do

Votes, trade, war and alliance

Topic by topic

Overall agreement hides what separates two governments. Here it is counted per issue.

Middle East: the vote agreement fell from 99% (2010–14) to 85% (2020–25).

  • All roll-call votes 98% (range 97–98%) since 2010, 1465 votes · 97% all years 2010–14: 97% 2015–19: 96% 2020–25: 94%
  • Disarmament 100% (range 98–100%) since 2010, 178 votes · 99% all years 2010–14: 100% 2015–19: 100%
  • Middle East 97% (range 94–99%) since 2010, 193 votes · 98% all years 2010–14: 99% 2015–19: 97% 2020–25: 85%
  • Human rights 97% (range 94–98%) since 2010, 248 votes · 97% all years 2010–14: 96% 2015–19: 93% 2020–25: 89%
  • Colonialism 98% (range 94–100%) since 2010, 97 votes · 97% all years 2010–14: 95% 2015–19: 100%
  • Nuclear weapons 99% (range 96–100%) since 2010, 200 votes · 98% all years 2010–14: 100% 2015–19: 98% 2020–25: 96%
  • Economic development 98% (range 93–100%) since 2010, 93 votes · 95% all years 2010–14: 100% 2015–19: 94%

Vote agreement on roll-call votes, counted vote by vote the same way as the headline figure: the same vote counts 1, an abstention against a yes or a no ½, a yes against a no 0. Votes on amendments and single paragraphs are left out. Topics are the labels of the UN voting dataset; one resolution can carry several, and about 60% carry none. Disarmament, colonialism and economic development are coded together from 2019, so they count votes up to 2018. Bar: 2010–2025; mark: all years. Shares need at least five shared votes. The thin line on each bar is the 95% sampling range given the number of votes.

Votes that set them apart

Since 2010 they voted on 1465 whole-text resolutions together. On 1 one said yes and the other no; they differed in some way on 66. All of them, newest first: (the API lists up to 50: API)

Roll-call votes on whole texts at the UN General Assembly, since 2010; amendments and single paragraphs are left out, as in the topic bars. Titles and document symbols: UN Digital Library via Nations on Record; votes: Voeten et al. A vote is not a statement about the other country, only about the text.

Voting positions over time

Each year's position on the main dimension of UN voting, with its 90% range. Where the shaded ranges overlap, the votes of that year cannot tell the two apart. The gap was 0.12 in 1973 and is 0.10 in 2025; it was widest in 1976 (0.22).

+0.5+1.0+1.5+2.0+2.5 19801990200020102020

Germany Belgium

Show data table
YearGermany90% rangeBelgium90% range
20250.970.84 – 1.120.880.75 – 1.01
20241.130.97 – 1.31.020.87 – 1.19
20231.160.97 – 1.350.970.82 – 1.14
20221.231.03 – 1.431.010.83 – 1.19
20211.070.91 – 1.230.960.8 – 1.12
20201.211.03 – 1.391.010.87 – 1.17
20191.090.94 – 1.240.980.83 – 1.14
20181.090.93 – 1.250.960.8 – 1.12
20171.110.95 – 1.290.960.78 – 1.13
20161.150.97 – 1.341.040.86 – 1.22
20151.180.99 – 1.371.010.83 – 1.18
20141.150.97 – 1.330.990.83 – 1.18
20131.030.83 – 1.230.950.75 – 1.15
20120.920.73 – 1.110.970.78 – 1.15
20110.920.72 – 1.131.020.82 – 1.23
20101.010.82 – 1.20.970.79 – 1.16
20091.070.86 – 1.271.030.84 – 1.22
20080.830.65 – 1.010.940.74 – 1.13
20070.870.69 – 1.050.950.77 – 1.14
20060.940.75 – 1.151.00.81 – 1.19
20050.960.77 – 1.161.020.82 – 1.22
20041.00.8 – 1.190.990.8 – 1.18
20031.150.96 – 1.351.120.94 – 1.32
20021.130.93 – 1.331.110.91 – 1.31
20011.170.94 – 1.391.130.91 – 1.35
20001.210.97 – 1.431.190.95 – 1.4
19991.261.04 – 1.491.190.98 – 1.41
19981.231.0 – 1.491.241.01 – 1.48
19971.51.26 – 1.761.451.21 – 1.7
19961.551.29 – 1.811.571.31 – 1.84
19951.531.29 – 1.791.561.3 – 1.84
19941.521.29 – 1.781.541.28 – 1.8
19931.581.37 – 1.81.541.34 – 1.77
19921.561.36 – 1.781.551.36 – 1.76
19911.71.5 – 1.891.711.52 – 1.9
19901.821.65 – 1.991.811.64 – 1.99
19891.881.73 – 2.041.771.62 – 1.93
19881.931.8 – 2.061.81.67 – 1.93
19871.851.71 – 2.01.791.63 – 1.92
19861.911.77 – 2.031.811.67 – 1.94
19851.861.72 – 1.981.811.68 – 1.94
19841.781.65 – 1.91.691.56 – 1.83
19831.711.57 – 1.841.61.47 – 1.72
19821.691.57 – 1.811.691.56 – 1.82
19811.831.69 – 1.971.661.52 – 1.81
19801.841.68 – 1.991.811.65 – 1.98
19791.991.83 – 2.151.911.76 – 2.06
19781.891.71 – 2.071.691.51 – 1.88
19771.951.76 – 2.141.851.66 – 2.04
19762.272.07 – 2.482.041.84 – 2.24
19752.031.82 – 2.271.851.64 – 2.08
19741.711.48 – 1.941.71.49 – 1.91
19731.61.39 – 1.81.481.28 – 1.67

Positions are the ideal points of Bailey, Strezhnev and Voeten, estimated from every recorded vote; higher means voting more like the United States and Western democracies. They are not a moral score. Source: Nations on Record (Bailey, Strezhnev and Voeten).

On the UN voting map

In 2020–24 both voted in the same bloc, with United States, Japan and 37 others (41 countries in all). They were in the same bloc in all 6 periods since 1946.

Loading the map…

Drag the year to see how the blocs changed since 1946.

Each dot is a country, placed by how alike it voted that year: close dots voted alike. Colours are voting blocs, groups of countries among each other's closest voting partners in that period. The axes have no units; the United States is kept on the right and China at the top. Click a dot to open that country's pair with Germany. Source: Nations on Record, which shows the blocs in full. Inside the blocs (Nations on Record). Never part of a score.

Friends in common

The countries each one votes most alike with at the UN. Countries in the middle vote alike with both.

Trade over time

Germany sells to BelgiumBelgium sells to Germany

Goods exports, current US dollars. IMF via Nations on Record.

Who needs whom

Arrow width: yearly goods flow in each direction (2023–2025). Bars: share of each country's total trade.

Security

Both are members of NATO.

Counted: the two governments on opposite sides, or one sending troops to fight against the other. Fighting with armed groups based in the other country is not counted. UCDP Dyadic Dataset 26.1, data to 2025.

Shared clubs

European Unionsame UN regional group

EU, African Union, Arab League, ASEAN, BRICS, G7, G20, GCC, the P5 and UN regional groups. NATO counts under Security.

Trade agreements

They share one trade agreement notified to the WTO: EU Treaty.

  • EU Treaty · customs union, services agreement · in force since 1958

Agreements notified to the WTO, in force or signed. When a bloc such as the EU signs as one party, the agreement links its members with the other side, not with each other. The status is as notified to the WTO; whether an agreement is still applied between these two countries is not checked. Source: WTO Regional Trade Agreements database.

Sanctions

Neither applies a UN, EU, US or UK sanctions regime to the other.

Country regimes of the UN Security Council, the EU, the United States and the United Kingdom; thematic lists (terrorism, cyber, human rights) are left out, and so are other countries' own lists. A regime can target a government, officials or companies; it is not a measure of the relationship. Sources: EU Sanctions Map, OFAC (US Treasury), UK government. Never part of a score.

04 · Live

Between people

Governments argue; people move, study, flee and play football. None of this enters the index.

Living in the other country

born in Germany

UN DESA gives no figure for people born in Belgium living in Germany.

International migrant stock, UN DESA 2024. By place of birth: this includes refugees, and people born before today's borders, for example in a state that later split.

Refugees & asylum seekers
5
from Germany in Belgium (2020)
9
from Belgium in Germany (2025)

UNHCR. Refugees and asylum seekers only: people given citizenship on arrival are not counted.

Ask about Germany & BelgiumLocal AI · answers only from this page's data · numbers checked

The answers are written by an AI language model, not by the site's editors. It can be wrong; the numbers and sources on this page are the reference.

What changed recently

  • Voting together: about the same (97% in 2022–2024).
  • Trade: up 4% ($163 billion → $170 billion a year).
  • Sentences naming each other at the UN: 1 in the last five General Debates, 2 in the five before.

Sources & coverage

  • Speeches, mentions, votes, trade: Nations on Record, loaded 2026-10-12 20:33 UTC.
  • UCDP Dyadic and Battle-Related Deaths datasets, version 26.1, loaded 2026-11-14 20:06 UTC.
  • UN DESA International Migrant Stock 2024, loaded 2026-10-12 20:18 UTC. UNHCR Refugee Population Statistics (api.unhcr.org), 2000–2025, loaded 2026-10-12 20:18 UTC.
  • International football results 1872–present (Mart Jürisoo, CC0), loaded 2026-10-12 20:18 UTC.
  • Scoring rules 0.4 (14 Nov 2026), scores built 2026-11-14 21:20 UTC. Every rule.